Published on:

Breakthrough in the Effort to Obtain Full Part B Reimbursement for Hospitals with Inpatient Claims Denied for Medical Necessity

Since the RAC Demonstration Program launched in 2005 and the final RAC program launched in 2008, Wachler & Associates, P.C. has been instrumental in the effort to obtain full Part B outpatient reimbursement for hospitals where a short-stay inpatient claim has been denied for lack of medical necessity. Although our legal arguments for Part B payment resonated with many administrative law judges (ALJs) and ALJs would issue orders for full Part B reimbursement, we have been trying to establish a precise process to effectuate the orders for full Part B reimbursement, including observation services. Last week, after our ongoing communication with Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) and a Medicare Administrative Contractor, we obtained a CMS memorandum which provides a very specific avenue for hospitals to obtain full Part B reimbursement in the event that an inpatient claim is denied as not being medically necessary and reasonable and the ALJ issues an order for outpatient observation services.

The CMS memorandum dated July 13, 2012, is from a number of officials from CMS to “All Fiscal Intermediaries (FIs), Carriers, and Part A and Part B Medicare Administrative Contractors (A/B MACs)”. The memorandum explains that there have been multiple ALJ decisions where the ALJ has upheld the contractors’ denials of the inpatient services as not reasonable and necessary, but then ordered the contractor to pay the hospital full Medicare Part B outpatient reimbursement, including observation. As a result of these ALJ orders, CMS issued mandatory instructions for claims administration contractors to follow in the event that an ALJ decision instructs CMS to make payments for Medicare Part B outpatient/observation services. Most importantly, the instructions require contractors to contact the provider to obtain a Part B claim within 30 calendar days of receipt of the effectuation notice from the Administrative QIC (AdQIC). The instructions note that an order for outpatient/observation services is only required if the ALJ did not specify payment for observation level of care. In instances where the ALJ’s specified coverage of “observation level of care,” observation charges may be added to the replacement claim, as the ALJ is specifically substituting the order to admit for the order for observation. The provider must send the replacement claim to the contractor within 180 days from the date the contractor contacts the provider or else the contractor must close the case and consider effectuation completed.

While the memorandum states that the Manuals do not provide support for this position, CMS recognizes that ALJs are issuing orders for Part B observation services and are directing the claims administration contractors to effectuate an adjusted payment to the hospital in accordance with these decisions. As such, CMS issued this memorandum to clearly instruct claims administration contractors how to effectuate an ALJ’s order for payment for Part B observation services.

Wachler & Associates believes that this is an extremely important advancement in the effort to obtain accurate payment for hospitals where an inpatient short-stay claim has been denied for lack of medical necessity. Although there is still more work to be done to solidify hospitals’ ability to obtain Part B reimbursement, this memo is the most clear indication that we have received from CMS that contractors are now required to effectuate an ALJ’s order for Part B reimbursement. Persuading an ALJ to order payment for observation and all underlying outpatient care is a legal, not a clinical, argument. We have a number of legal arguments and authorities that we rely upon to persuade a judge to issue a precise order for Part B reimbursement, including observation services and underlying outpatient care.

For more information on Wachler & Associates efforts in the advancement of full outpatient/observation reimbursement or for assistance with the appeal of inpatient short stay claim denials, please contact Andrew Wachler or Jennifer Colagiovanni at 248-544-0888.